VVAW: Vietnam Veterans Against the War
VVAW Home
About VVAW
Contact Us
Membership
Commentary
Image Gallery
Upcoming Events
Vet Resources
VVAW Store
THE VETERAN
FAQ


Donate
THE VETERAN

Page 23
Download PDF of this full issue: v56n2.pdf (37.4 MB)

<< 22. Thank You For Your Service24. Outside the Perimeter (poem) >>

The Last Vietnam War: Who Won?

By Steven Jonas

[Printer-Friendly Version]

Ken Burns' self-styled documentary, The Vietnam War, has prompted numerous writers' commentaries on the film itself and the accompanying book, on the War, on the US role, on the aftermath, and so on. One question about the horror (primarily for the people of Indo-China, most especially Vietnam) that does not get asked too often has been"who won?" The conventional wisdom on the Right, the Center, and at least some of the Left, is that the US lost. Well, if one goes back to the history of the War and reviews the United States' original goals, it becomes very clear that, in fact, the US won. And here's the case for making that statement.

Ho Chi Minh (a nom de plume [how appropriately French, non?]), the once-and-future leader of a united Vietnam, made his first appearance on the world stage at the post-World War I Paris Peace Conference in 1919. Among other things, he attempted to approach one of the primary Conference leaders, US President Woodrow Wilson. He wanted to request support in getting the then-French colonial authorities to establish basic civil rights for the Vietnamese population. (France had conquered what became"French Indo-China," beginning in the 1850s.) But the racist Wilson's famous "Fourteen Points" of "self-determination" apparently only applied to nations occupied by white folks. (Wilson, racist, you say? Well yes. Among other things, it was Wilson who re-segregated the US armed forces, as well as the bulk of the US civil service.) Wilson simply fobbed off Ho Chi Minh. Vietnam reverted to French rule, with no changes to the status of the local population. Ho Chi Minh (now a nom de guerre) and his allies began an armed liberation movement during the 1920s.

During the Second World War, French Indo-China was actually administered jointly by the Nazi-collaborationist regime of Vichy France and the Japanese, who had captured the whole of Southeast Asia in 1940-42. After the War, Ho Chi Minh and his liberationist forces asked the (non-French) Allies to prevent the re-establishment of the French colonial regime. They were rebuffed, as they had been in Paris in 1919. Then began the French-Vietnamese War, which ended with the surrender of the French at Dien Bien Phu in 1954. The Geneva Peace Conference and Agreement between the French and the victorious Vietnamese forces in 1954 followed this. The United Kingdom and the Soviet Union guaranteed it. Pointedly, the United States refused to guarantee, endorse, or even accept the Agreement.

Although the Ho Chi Minh-led forces had won the War, there was a pro-French puppet government in the South, headed by the "emperor" Bao Dai. And so, the Agreement divided the country into something that had never previously existed: a "North" and a "South." This was supposed to be a temporary arrangement, until national elections—elections that everyone knew would have been won overwhelmingly by Ho Chi Minh and his Communist Party—were to be held in 1956. The US interest, not at all in sync with the Paris Agreement, was led by the fiercely anti-Communist Secretary of State John Foster Dulles and his equally fiercely anti-Communist brother, Allen Dulles, director of the Central Intelligence Agency.

One of the primary goals of the Dulles brothers, and indeed their ideological successors who have dominated US foreign policy down to this very day, was to prevent the peaceful establishment of any form of socialism or anything that looked anything like it, in any country around the world. With the exception of Cuba, they have been largely successful. As noted, the US refused to sign or recognize the 1954 treaty. The Dulleses knew that if the plan in it were allowed to proceed, the chances were very good that Vietnam would peacefully progress to socialism and be an economic success at it. If that happened, the same thing might well occur peacefully in many other Southeast Asian countries were democracy given a chance. At that time, it appeared there might be a democratic, peaceful road to socialism that could be emulated around the world. Not good for US-led Western Imperialism. When looked at from that perspective, yes, the "domino theory" about the potential spread of socialism was quite correct.

And so, in the view of the US leadership of the time, everything that could be done to prevent the democratic process from introducing socialism to a country and then possibly succeeding in a peaceful setting had to be done. And so, with the puppet Bao Dai in place, the promised elections were put off again and again. Eventually, a national resistance movement, labeled the "Viet Cong" by the US and its puppet, arose, and then US forces, first as "advisors," were sent in. Then what became the "North Vietnamese" army (again, remember that "North Vietnam" was an entirely artificial construct) was drawn into it, and what became the "Vietnam War" occurred.

And yes, in the end, the United States seemed to have lost militarily. Under enormous pressure at home, and an inability to actually win on the battlefield in Vietnam (all of course complicated by "Watergate"), President Richard M. Nixon began the military disengagement. The final pullout, with those haunting photographs of people leaving by helicopter from the roof of the US embassy in Saigon as the legitimate government of Vietnam led by its armed forces entered the city, occurred under President Ford. But, and this is the important BUT, if one examines what happened in terms of the original goals for the US Vietnam intervention, set by Eisenhower and the Dulles brothers in the 1950's, the US won: those goals were achieved. The Vietnam War was actually a US victory.

The peaceful establishment of socialism, as the result of a popular vote, no less, was prevented. Its spread by example and peaceful means to neighboring countries was prevented. The country is still trying to cope with the widespread use of Agent Orange by US forces, massive "carpet-bombing" of non-strategic areas, and unexploded ordnance. Vietnam today has a sort of market socialist economy, but the country was ravaged by almost 20 years of War, and two to four million of the best and the brightest of its people were killed. It is hardly the economic or social engine for the development of democratically installed socialism that it might have become had it been left alone. And so yes, in terms of the original American goals for the intervention, a win, a palpable win.

As for Ken Burns' film, in the Prologue he says that the war "was begun in good faith, by decent people." Well, no, Ken, it wasn't. From the time the ink was dry on the signing page of the 1954 Geneva Agreement, the United States, led by indecent people, was working to undermine it, which eventually led directly to the War. And no, Mr. David Greenberg, while you may say that "The Vietnam War: An Intimate History tells once again the painful tale of America's protracted, divisive and (most would now agree) futile involvement in the fight to keep South Vietnam unconquered by the Communist North [emphasis added]," the division into North and South was something brand-new to Vietnam and was supposed to be only an administrative one, until those elections could have been held by 1956.

The US role in Vietnam has to be seen in the context of the (eventually successful) "75 Years War Against the Soviet Union" (1917-92), and the serial prevention of the peaceful establishment of socialist or even moderately left-wing, anti-colonialist, governments, around the world (see, e.g., Korea, 1945, Iran, 1953, Congo, 1960, Brazil, 1964, Chile, 1973, Afghanistan, 1978-86, Nicaragua, 1980s, etc.).

Yes, indeed, once again, in terms of the original goals of US Imperialism, led in the 1950's by the infamous Dulles Brothers, for the US, the Vietnam War was a win, a palpable win.

P.S.: Why the "Last Vietnam War" of the title? Well, in addition to the US war of aggression, there was the original French conquest in the 1850s-60s, the anti-French liberation movement of the 1920s-30s, the Japanese conquest in 1940, and the Vietnamese-French War of 1946-53.


Steven Jonas, MD, MPH, MS, is a Professor Emeritus of Preventive Medicine at Stony Brook Medicine (NY) and author/co-author/editor/co-editor of over 35 books. His most recent book on US politics is The 15% Solution: How the Republican Religious Right Took Control of the US, 1981-2022: A Futuristic Novel.



<< 22. Thank You For Your Service24. Outside the Perimeter (poem) >>